Still working to recover. Please don't edit quite yet.
Difference between revisions of "nationalist anarchism"
From Anarchopedia
m (→Anarchist critique of National Anarchism: spelling) |
m (→Anarchist critique of National Anarchism: changed title, capitalised word, spelling) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
Anarcho-nationalism is a concept that derives from Ancient Greece and in particular autonomist philosopher [[Zeno]]. Anarcho- nationalists believe in autonomy of different region based on the ancient Greek system of Cities- "States". The difference with the other anarchists is that while other anarchists ([[anarcho-communism|Anarcho-communists]] etc) are internationalists , anarcho-nationalists are strongly nationalists ( but without being racists). This again derives from the ancient greek patriotism. In short anarcho-nationalism derives from the ancient Greek [[autonomy]] , but it rejects ancient Greek economy and having traces of exploitation, imperialism and a market economy. Anarcho- nationalists are Collectivists. So they combine collectivsm , with ancient Greek autonomism and patriotism. An example of anarcho- Nationalists in the recent years are anarchists in Catalonia who were very patriotic and nationalistic. | Anarcho-nationalism is a concept that derives from Ancient Greece and in particular autonomist philosopher [[Zeno]]. Anarcho- nationalists believe in autonomy of different region based on the ancient Greek system of Cities- "States". The difference with the other anarchists is that while other anarchists ([[anarcho-communism|Anarcho-communists]] etc) are internationalists , anarcho-nationalists are strongly nationalists ( but without being racists). This again derives from the ancient greek patriotism. In short anarcho-nationalism derives from the ancient Greek [[autonomy]] , but it rejects ancient Greek economy and having traces of exploitation, imperialism and a market economy. Anarcho- nationalists are Collectivists. So they combine collectivsm , with ancient Greek autonomism and patriotism. An example of anarcho- Nationalists in the recent years are anarchists in Catalonia who were very patriotic and nationalistic. | ||
| − | ==Anarchist | + | ==Classical Anarchist Critique of National Anarchism== |
{{critique section}} | {{critique section}} | ||
# Anarchist movement provides unifying power to all the people | # Anarchist movement provides unifying power to all the people | ||
| − | ## National Anarchism allows the group to exclude | + | ## National Anarchism allows the group to exclude certain groups. |
# Anarchism is anti-discriminatory in its nature | # Anarchism is anti-discriminatory in its nature | ||
| − | ## National Anarchism allows for | + | ## National Anarchism allows for uncontented [[racism]], [[homophobia]], [[biphobia]], [[transsexism]], [[sexism]], [[ageism]]. |
| − | # Anarchy implies elimination of borders between different | + | # Anarchy implies elimination of borders between different communities |
| − | ## National Anarchism | + | ## National Anarchism provides a way for community to make it harder for an individual to leave the group. |
| − | ## National Anarchism | + | ## National Anarchism provides a way for community to make it harder for an individual to pass through some physical location. |
# Anarchism is antiâ€[[ageism|ageist]] and antiâ€[[censorship]]. | # Anarchism is antiâ€[[ageism|ageist]] and antiâ€[[censorship]]. | ||
## National Anarchists allow parents to dominate their [[child]]renʼs information gathering. | ## National Anarchists allow parents to dominate their [[child]]renʼs information gathering. | ||
| − | Besides that | + | Besides that National Anarchism does not critique [[patriarchy]], [[heterosexism]], [[monosexism]], and many other forms of [[hierarchy|hierarchal]] social organisation. |
===Historical critique=== | ===Historical critique=== | ||
Revision as of 01:03, 31 December 2007
Anarcho-nationalism is a concept that derives from Ancient Greece and in particular autonomist philosopher Zeno. Anarcho- nationalists believe in autonomy of different region based on the ancient Greek system of Cities- "States". The difference with the other anarchists is that while other anarchists (Anarcho-communists etc) are internationalists , anarcho-nationalists are strongly nationalists ( but without being racists). This again derives from the ancient greek patriotism. In short anarcho-nationalism derives from the ancient Greek autonomy , but it rejects ancient Greek economy and having traces of exploitation, imperialism and a market economy. Anarcho- nationalists are Collectivists. So they combine collectivsm , with ancient Greek autonomism and patriotism. An example of anarcho- Nationalists in the recent years are anarchists in Catalonia who were very patriotic and nationalistic.
Classical Anarchist Critique of National Anarchism
- This section criticises the topic of the article from the perspective of anarchism. If possible, please keep criticism constructive.
- Anarchist movement provides unifying power to all the people
- National Anarchism allows the group to exclude certain groups.
- Anarchism is anti-discriminatory in its nature
- National Anarchism allows for uncontented racism, homophobia, biphobia, transsexism, sexism, ageism.
- Anarchy implies elimination of borders between different communities
- National Anarchism provides a way for community to make it harder for an individual to leave the group.
- National Anarchism provides a way for community to make it harder for an individual to pass through some physical location.
- Anarchism is antiâ€ageist and antiâ€censorship.
- National Anarchists allow parents to dominate their childrenʼs information gathering.
Besides that National Anarchism does not critique patriarchy, heterosexism, monosexism, and many other forms of hierarchal social organisation.
Historical critique
- Lincoln Brigades have been one of the first antiâ€nationalists, while proâ€capitalist forces were still supporting nationalism in Europe (see Spanish Revolution).
- Proudhon was called “half anarchist†even in his days for having racist and sexist parts to his philosophy.
