Still working to recover. Please don't edit quite yet.

Difference between revisions of "None of the above"

From Anarchopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
(Start)
 
(No difference)

Latest revision as of 22:04, 11 March 2012

None of the Above (NOTA) is a Wikipedia:ballot option in some Wikipedia:jurisdictions or Wikipedia:organizations, designed to allow the voter to indicate disapproval of all of the candidates in a Wikipedia:voting system. It is based on the principle that Wikipedia:consent requires the ability to withhold consent in an election, just as they can by voting no on ballot questions.

Entities that include "None of the Above" on ballots as standard procedure include Greece (WP) (λευκό, white, but unrelated to a political party of the similarly sounding name-however it is symbolic only), the Wikipedia:U.S. state of Wikipedia:Nevada (Wikipedia:None of These Candidates), the Wikipedia:Iowa caucuses ("no preference"), Ukraine (WP) (Проти всіх), Spain (WP) (voto en blanco), Colombia (WP) (voto en blanco), the United States Libertarian Party and Green Party and the Florida affiliate of the American Patriot Party.[1] Wikipedia:Russia had such an option on its ballots (Против всех) until it was abolished in 2006.[2] Bangladesh (WP) introduced this option (না ভোট) in 2008.[3]

When None of the Above is listed on a ballot, there is the possibility of NOTA receiving a Wikipedia:majority or plurality of the vote, and so "winning" the election. In such a case, a variety of formal procedures may be invoked, including having the office remain vacant, having the office filled by appointment, re-opening Wikipedia:nominations or holding another election (in a body operating under Wikipedia:parliamentary procedure).

In Nevada, the candidate with the greatest number of votes assumes office regardless of votes for None of the Above. None of the Above acts as a repository for Wikipedia:protest votes.[4]

The Wikipedia:Green Party of California included NOTA in its original 1991 bylaws, to offer voters a choice of rejecting all candidates presented. After one round of successful elections in which a candidate in Southern California and all Wikipedia:gubernatorial candidates were retired after the primary by NOTA, a lawsuit by the California Secretary of State led to the disallowal of NOTA in Green Party primaries.

In 2000, Wikipedia:Michael Moore advocated a Wikipedia:write-in candidate Ficus (the plant) for Congress as a unified vote for none of the above in congressional seats where the incumbent was running unopposed.[5]

In 2004, the Oklahoma Green, Libertarian and Constitution parties endorsed a NOTA campaign for president that was organized by Oklahomans for Ballot Access Reform. The campaign called for voters to leave the Presidential ballot line blank in protest of restrictive Wikipedia:ballot access laws.

Wikipedia:Ralph Nader ran as a NOTA candidate and supports the NOTA option as a method of voters to withhold consent and to initiate a new round of elections.

The Wikipedia:South Wales Anarchists group has run a campaign urging people to "Vote Nobody" since 2008[6] and many other Wikipedia:Anarchist groups worldwide have promoted similar slogans.

During the run up to the 2008 United States elections, Wikipedia:Beltaine's Fire, a Wikipedia:celtic hip hop band from California, released a song and a music video in support of such anti-parliamentary campaigns called "None of the Above" [7] urging people to "check other and write none of the above".

This article contains content from Wikipedia. Current versions of the GNU FDL article None of the above on WP may contain information useful to the improvement of this article WP

Re-open Nominations (RON)[edit]

Many students' unions in the Wikipedia:Britain and Ireland use a similar ballot option called re-open nominations (RON)[8] in IRV (also known as the alternative vote) and Wikipedia:single transferable vote (STV) elections. These include the National Union of Students in the UK and UCD Student's Union in the Wikipedia:Republic of Ireland. The difference is that RON is a vote against all candidates in FPTP (first-past-the-post) and all subsequent candidates in an IRV or STV election.

There are several ways of dealing with a RON candidate. In a single member constituency or election to a single position RON is treated as a normal candidate. If re-open nominations is deemed elected to any position then at the end of the count that position is declared vacant and nominations must later be re-opened for that position.

In a multi-member constituency there are two approaches. In the first, when a RON candidate is elected, all other candidates below RON are declared not to be elected and the counting process stops, the election is then re-run for that and all other unfilled positions. In the second, RON is elected to a position, then any surplus is transferred to another RON(2) candidate as if such an option had been presented on the ballot paper. If RON(2) is elected, then the process carries on with RON(3), RON(4) candidates and so on until all seats are filled. This is sometimes called the Stack RON method.

RON is not strictly a none of the above candidate in transferable vote elections, as when RON is eliminated during the count its votes are transferred to other candidates if those preferences exist.

None of the Above candidates[edit]

  • In the British parliamentary elections of 2010, a former boxer changed his name by Wikipedia:deed poll from Terry Marsh to "None Of The Above X", in order to run as a parliamentary candidate under that name in the constituency of South Basildon and East Thurrock. Claiming that he will not take the seat if he wins, he told BBC Essex: "I don't take it for one moment that it would be a vote for me. [..] I'm doing what I think the Electoral Commission should be doing and what should be on every ballot paper in any electoral process." BBC News reported that, while the Registration of Political Parties (Prohibited Words and Expressions) (Amendment) Order 2005 stipulates that no political party can be registered in the UK under the name "None of the Above", there is no legislation against a person changing their name by deed poll and appearing on the ballot paper as "None Of the Above".[9] In the event he polled 0.3% of the vote, the lowest of any candidate standing.[10]
  • Another individual changed his name by deed poll to None Of The Above in order to stand as a candidate in Chingford and Woodford Green in 2010. With the surname Above, he was listed first on the ballot paper in alphabetical order, with all the other candidates listed below.
  • A Prince George businessman ran in the June 2, 1997 Canadian election in the district of Prince George-Bulkley Valley[11] under the name Zznoneoff, Thea Bove (Thea Bove Zznoneoff); ballots listing candidates alphabetically by surname, he appeared at the bottom. He came sixth of seven candidates with 0.977 percent of votes cast.
  • In the film Brewster's Millions, the protagonist Brewster (played by Wikipedia:Richard Pryor) is required under certain conditions, to spend 30 million dollars in 30 days. He joins the race for Mayor of Wikipedia:New York City and throws most of his money at a protest campaign urging a vote for None of the Above. The two major candidates sue Brewster for his confrontational rhetoric, leading to a massive settlement which of course furthers their competitor's goal. Brewster is forced to end his campaign when he learns that he is leading in the polls as a write-in candidate and has to publicly announce that he if he won the mayoralty he wants to decline it but is surprised his "None of the Above" campaign became so popular. Oddly neither candidate wins the election, and a new election with different candidates must be held.
  • Wikipedia:L. Neil Smith's novel Wikipedia:The Probability Broach has an Wikipedia:alternate history of the United States, where None of the Above has received the most votes for President of the Wikipedia:North American Confederacy on multiple occasions.
  • Wikipedia:David Gatchell of Wikipedia:Tennessee ran for governor in 2002 and for Senate in 2006 as a protest, officially changing his middle name from Leroy to None of the Above.[12] In 2006, he got 3,738 votes (0.2 percent).
  • Geoff Richardson changed his full name to "Of The Above None" and stood as an independent for the seat of Gilmore at the 2007 Australian federal election. His name appeared as NONE, Of the Above on the ballot.[13]
  • In Wikipedia:Serbia, None of the above (Ниједан од понуђених одговора, NOPO) is a new party, formed in 2008, which became mostly popularized on Wikipedia:Facebook and other social networking sites.
  • In Wikipedia:Ukrainian presidential election, 2010, a candidate Vasiliy Humeniuk changed his name to Wikipedia:Vasily Protyvsih (Vasily Against-all). "Against all candidates" is the name of the "none of the above" vote used in Russia and Ukraine.[14][15]

United Kingdom[edit]

NOTA party[edit]

NOTA was registered as a political party with the UK Electoral Commission on 2 March 2009.[16] It is the intention of NOTA to field candidates in every UK parliamentary constituency. The respective NOTA candidates will not continue in office should they receive the most votes. It is merely a mechanism to facilitate a means of recording a NOTA vote. This party is registered as "NOTA" and not "None of the above" as the latter is a prohibited expression regarding registration as a party name.[17]

No Candidate Deserves My Vote! party[edit]

"No Candidate Deserves My Vote!" was registered as a political party with the UK Electoral Commission on 23 November 2000.[18] The No Candidate Deserves My Vote party has one aim, and that is to introduce a bill to Parliament to have a "None of the above" option added to every local and general election ballot paper of the future. They feel this will allow the UK electorate to exercise their democratic right to vote to say that none of the parties currently represents them, which will encourage their democratic responsibility to turn out to vote. If a candidate wins an election it is the intention to stay as an MP until the change in the law is enacted. Only then will the candidate step down and the party be disbanded.

It is the intention of the party that if a NOTA gains the majority vote that it should cause an automatic Wikipedia:by-election. The idea being that the majority have given a Wikipedia:Vote of No Confidence in the candidates. If the same candidates stand under the same policies then the electorate simply vote NOTA until the candidates change their policies to something that the electorate can vote for.

In 2010, Stephen Phillips of Wikipedia:Stevenage ran for the UK General Election on behalf of No Candidate Deserves My Vote.[19] Phillips received 327 votes, or 0.7% of the vote, placing 7th out of 9 candidates.[20]

Landless Peasant Party[edit]

The Landless Peasant Party, which advocates the ownership of land by those who live on it and the replacement of income tax by a flat land tax,[21] and whose leader Derek Jackson gained publicity for standing against then- Prime Minister Gordon Brown in his home constituency in the 2010 elections,[22] include a pledge to add a "None of the above" option to the ballot in all UK elections.[21]

Zero, None Of the Above[edit]

None Of The Above Zero was a candidate at the Wikipedia:2010 UK General Election in Filton and Bradley Stoke.[23] Previously known as Eric Mutch, he changed his name by deed poll to stand under that name. As candidates are listed by surname first he appeared on the ballot paper as "Zero, None Of The Above,"[24] in effect giving voters a none of the above option since had he been elected he would have resigned immediately.[25] He came last with 172 votes.[26]

Spain[edit]

Blank ballot[edit]

Due to the Spanish voting regulations (legislación electoral española), the blank ballot is recognized as None of the above (voto en blanco) but has very little chance to influence the distribution of seats within a democratic election. It is mostly considered as an statistical indicator of candidatures' disapproval. The blank ballots only increase the amount of valid votes, rising up the threshold of votes (3% and 5% depending on the election) which every political party has to overcome to be fully considered. The parties over the threshold get their seats according to the Wikipedia:D'Hondt method.

Blank seats (Escaños en blanco)[edit]

Since 1999, several political parties[27][28][29][30][31] have arosen in order to make visible the None of the above option in the parliaments and force empty seats. Currently, "Blank Seats" runs for the Congress and Senate elections of the 20th November 2011. Its programme is to leave empty the corresponding assigned seats by not taken full possession of their duties as congressperson, senator, etc. According to law, the seat remains assigned to the elected candidate until the possession act takes place, the elected candidate explicitely refuses or new elections are called. In this way, the political party and its candidates stay free from obligations and are not entitled to receive any money from the public funding scheme for politics.

By voting such option at the local elections in May 2011, the citizens of the villages of Gironella (Barcelona) and Foixà (Girona) were able to reduce the amount of politicians in their councils by one and two respectively.[32][33] Overall, citizenship supported Blank Seats at different municipalities, including Barcelona, with 15582 votes (averaging 1,71% of valid votes).

This party aims to give blank ballots the meaning of representing empty seats if the amount of votes indicate so as for any other party, disbanding the party when such law would be approved.

Illegal ballots in Robert's Rules of Order[edit]

The U.S. manual Robert's Rules of Order, Newly Revised, 10th edition, p. 402 describes various forms of illegal ballots, which are ballots which do not count for any candidate. Blanks are treated as "scrap paper" and are of no effect but "unintelligible ballots or ballots cast for an unidentifiable candidate or a fictional character are treated as illegal votes. "All illegal votes cast by legal voters… are taken into account in determining the number of votes cast for purposes of computing the majority." RRONR always requires a majority for election so casting an illegal ballot or one for a hopeless candidate, whether on the ballot or as a write-in, is equivalent to voting No for all other candidates. "The principle is that a choice has no mandate from the voting body unless approval is expressed by more than half of those entitled to vote and registering any evidence of having some opinion."

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ↑ http://www.americanpatriotparty.cc
  2. ↑ Russians Divided Over Electoral Reforms: Angus Reid Global Monitor. Angus-reid.com. URL accessed on 2010-09-01.
  3. ↑ "Bangladesh amends election law incorporating 'no' vote option". Times of India. Jul 14, 2008. http://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2008-07-14/rest-of-world/27918086_1_general-elections-votes-amendment. Retrieved 26 September 2011. </li>
  4. ↑ Las Vegas Sun, November 8th 2006
  5. ↑ Ficus Plant Announces Candidacy For Congress
  6. ↑ South Wales Anarchists. South Wales Anarchists. URL accessed on 2010-09-01.
  7. ↑ None of the Above : Beltaine’s Fire. Beltainesfire.com. URL accessed on 2010-09-01. Template:Dead link
  8. ↑ Make Votes Count In West Sussex. Mvcwestsussex.org.uk. URL accessed on 2010-09-01.
  9. ↑ Basildon boxer to fight election as 'None Of The Above', BBC News, (27 April 2010)
  10. ↑ "BBC NEWS – Election 2010 – Basildon South & Thurrock East". BBC News. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/shared/election2010/results/constituency/e08.stm. </li>
  11. ↑ http://www2.parl.gc.ca/Sites/LOP/HFER/hfer.asp?Language=E&Search=Gres&genElection=36&ridProvince=2&submit1=Search
  12. ↑ [1]Template:Dead link
  13. ↑ About. None Of The Above. URL accessed on 2010-09-01.
  14. ↑ CEC registers two more candidates for Ukraine's president, Wikipedia:Interfax-Ukraine (November 6, 2009)
  15. ↑ Three candidates united by disgust with authorities, Wikipedia:Kyiv Post (November 19, 2009)
  16. ↑ NOTA. Electoral Commission. URL accessed on 2009-07-08.
  17. ↑ Registration of Political Parties (Prohibited Words and Expressions) (Amendment) Order 2005 at legislation.gov.uk
  18. ↑ No Candidate Deserves My Vote!. Electoral Commission. URL accessed on 2010-03-09.
  19. ↑ http://www.steveofstevenage.org.uk Steve of Stevenage
  20. ↑ http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/shared/election2010/results/constituency/e43.stm "Stevenage." BBC.
  21. ↑ 21.0 21.1 Election Manifesto 2010 / Landless Peasant Party. Landlesspeasants.org. URL accessed on 2010-09-01.
  22. ↑ General Election 2010: Derek Jackson, the man with his fist up behind Gordon Brown, becomes a Facebook hit. Metro.co.uk. URL accessed on 2010-09-01.
  23. ↑ Filton and Bradley Stoke, UK Polling Report, http://ukpollingreport.co.uk/guide/seat-profiles/filtonandbradleystoke, retrieved 7 May 2010 </li>
  24. ↑ None of the above, says name-change Bristol candidate, Wikipedia:Bristol: Wikipedia:Bristol Evening Post, 7 April 2010, http://www.thisisbristol.co.uk/news/says-change-Bristol-candidate/article-1979014-detail/article.html, retrieved 7 May 2010 </li>
  25. ↑ Mr ‘None of the Above’ Zero set to stand in Filton and Bradley Stoke, Wikipedia:Bristol: The Bradley Stoke Journal, 11 April 2010, http://www.bradleystokejournal.co.uk/plus/2010/04/11/none-above-stand-filton-bradley-stoke-election/, retrieved 7 May 2010 </li>
  26. ↑ Wakefield, Kate (10 May 2010), As it happened: Bristol Election 2010, BBC, http://news.bbc.co.uk/local/bristol/hi/people_and_places/newsid_8651000/8651796.stm </li>
  27. ↑ ESCAÑOS VACIOS (ESCAÑOS VACIOS). Registry of political parties of the Interior Ministry of Spain (spanish).
  28. ↑ ESCONS INSUBMISOS-ALTERNATIVA DELS DEMOCRATES DESCONTENTS (Ei). Registry of political parties of the Interior Ministry of Spain (spanish).
  29. ↑ CIUDADANOS EN BLANCO (CENB). Registry of political parties of the Interior Ministry of Spain (spanish).
  30. ↑ ALTERNATIVA EN BLANCO (ABLA). Registry of political parties of the Interior Ministry of Spain (spanish).
  31. ↑ ESCONS EN BLANC/ESCAÑOS EN BLANCO (Eb). Registry of political parties of the Interior Ministry of Spain (spanish).
  32. ↑ Escons en blanc dejará tres concejalías vacias en Cataluña. 8 June 2011. Europa Press (spanish).
  33. ↑ Escons en Blanc aconsegueix que tres cadires quedin buides als consistoris catalans. Ara.cat (catalan)

    34. </ol>

External links[edit]

Retrieved from "http://eng.anarchopedia.org/index.php?title=None_of_the_above&oldid=50624"