Still working to recover. Please don't edit quite yet.

Difference between revisions of "gift economy"

From Anarchopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
m (Reverted edits by 216.68.101.35 (Talk); changed back to last version by Koekje)
Line 1: Line 1:
−
[http://blueachimidicevideo.kittiss.cn/index.html blue a chi mi dice video] [http://bigliettidinvito.midways.cn/index.html biglietti d invito] [http://snailtail.cn/xellos/index.html xellos] [http://bolletteenel.kittiss.cn/index.html bollette enel] [http://knock-knock.cn/www-ondulit/index.html www ondulit it] [http://bianchinav7.romanikki.cn/index.html bianchina v7] [http://knock-knock.cn/windows2000/index.html windows2000] [http://knock-knock.cn/www-bomboniere/index.html www bomboniere it] [http://kitmun.cn/yma.html yma] [http://kitmun.cn/zaoco.html zaoco] [http://wonted.cn/www-costa/index.html www costa e ale it] [http://quoits.cn/amore-in.html amore in volo] [http://knock-knock.cn/www-cofidis-it/index.html www cofidis it] [http://bdsm.clung.cn/index.html bdsm] [http://brighton.midways.cn/index.html brighton] [http://beforeyouacuseme.clung.cn/index.html before you acuse me] [http://knock-knock.cn/walk-of-life/index.html walk of life] [http://knock-knock.cn/www-sapienza/index.html www sapienza com] [http://knock-knock.cn/www-pergamena/index.html www pergamena it] [http://knock-knock.cn/www-bresciaoggi/index.html www bresciaoggi] [http://boomshaka.kittiss.cn/index.html boom shaka] [http://blinddate.fast-road.cn/index.html blind date] [http://kitmun.cn/yo-me-acuerdo.html yo me acuerdo] [http://snailtail.cn/www-igre/index.html www igre com] [http://knock-knock.cn/www-mappy/index.html www mappy it] [http://biristabulmasali.midways.cn/index.html bir istabul masali] [http://bongo.kittiss.cn/index.html bongo] [http://brufoli.kittiss.cn/index.html brufoli] [http://brindisinotizie.clung.cn/index.html brindisi notizie] [http://quoits.cn/zacchini-federico.html zacchini federico] [http://kitmun.cn/zuma-deluxe.html zuma deluxe] [http://btittanymurphy.kittiss.cn/index.html btittany murphy] [http://knock-knock.cn/www-esmas/index.html www esmas] [http://berettaarmi.fast-road.cn/index.html beretta armi] [http://knock-knock.cn/www-iuventus/index.html www iuventus] [http://snailtail.cn/x-japan-the/index.html x japan the last song] [http://brokenfeaturingamylee.kittiss.cn/index.html broken featuring amy lee] [http://quoits.cn/anche-l'inferno.html anche l'inferno trema] [http://bitonalevvf.fast-road.cn/index.html bitonale vvf] [http://knock-knock.cn/www-cox/index.html www cox] [http://knock-knock.cn/www-negre/index.html www negre com] [http://baimidijazz.romanikki.cn/index.html bai midi jazz] [http://wonted.cn/www-pesadilla/index.html www pesadilla com] [http://wonted.cn/www-telepass/index.html www telepass itu] [http://knock-knock.cn/www-disneyblast/index.html www disneyblast it] [http://belsenwasagas.romanikki.cn/index.html belsen was a gas] [http://breakmachine.clung.cn/index.html break machine] [http://snailtail.cn/www-humour/index.html www humour com] [http://knock-knock.cn/whwre-is-the/index.html whwre is the love the black eyed peace] [http://snailtail.cn/yu-gi-oh-playstation/index.html yu gi oh playstation trucc] [http://binario.fast-road.cn/index.html binario] [http://wonted.cn/www-unicas/index.html www unicas it] [http://quoits.cn/zucconi-vittorio.html zucconi vittorio] [http://wonted.cn/www-vasco-canzone/index.html www vasco canzone it] [http://snailtail.cn/www-rwanda/index.html www rwanda del 94 it] [http://quoits.cn/azione-esecutiva.html azione esecutiva] [http://bigbrothers.midways.cn/index.html big brothers] [http://wonted.cn/www-s-c/index.html www s c mx] [http://snailtail.cn/xxx-free/index.html xxx free shemales] [http://baglionilivefullalbums.kittiss.cn/index.html baglioni live full albums] [http://knock-knock.cn/www-fortissimo/index.html www fortissimo com] [http://wonted.cn/www-misura/index.html www misura com] [http://babyqueen.clung.cn/index.html baby queen] [http://snailtail.cn/www-rire-org/index.html www rire org] [http://blueguily.midways.cn/index.html blue guily] [http://quoits.cn/zoog-disney.html zoog disney] [http://wonted.cn/www-cen-gov/index.html www cen gov ve] [http://knock-knock.cn/www-ceramicavandelli/index.html www ceramicavandelli it] [http://snailtail.cn/www-sis/index.html www sis unito it] [http://borgodolcianochiusi.kittiss.cn/index.html borgo dolciano chiusi] [http://berardoparadiso.kittiss.cn/index.html berardo paradiso] [http://knock-knock.cn/www-usatoday/index.html www usatoday com usa] [http://snailtail.cn/www-stefania/index.html www stefania orlando it] [http://wonted.cn/www-cocif-com/index.html www cocif com] [http://bigdaypuracane.romanikki.cn/index.html big day puracane] [http://snailtail.cn/www-sabots-you/index.html www sabots you you fr] [http://bellemature.fast-road.cn/index.html belle mature] [http://bersaglieri.kittiss.cn/index.html bersaglieri] [http://bonnietailor.clung.cn/index.html bonnie tailor] [http://snailtail.cn/www-tcp-it/index.html www tcp it] [http://bindguardian.romanikki.cn/index.html bind guardian] [http://budkasuflera.midways.cn/index.html budka suflera] [http://baisemoi.midways.cn/index.html baise moi] [http://snailtail.cn/www-protek/index.html www protek it] [http://kitmun.cn/yoo.html yoo] [http://behcetdisease.romanikki.cn/index.html behcet disease] [http://snailtail.cn/xxxxxxx/index.html xxxxxxx] [http://quoits.cn/appunti-per.html appunti per un'orestiade africana] [http://wonted.cn/www-raf-it/index.html www raf it] [http://kitmun.cn/yespica.html yespica] [http://billladen.fast-road.cn/index.html bill laden] [http://brigantsemore.clung.cn/index.html brigant se more] [http://quoits.cn/acque-di.html acque di primavera] [http://banbridge.clung.cn/index.html banbridge] [http://brigittekosics.clung.cn/index.html brigitte kosics] [http://bondedotigraothuthucafrescaboysm.kittiss.cn/index.html bonde do tigrao thu thuca fresca boys m] [http://knock-knock.cn/www-ciaociaoitaly/index.html www ciaociaoitaly it] [http://kitmun.cn/yankse-bin.html yankse bin] [http://quoits.cn/al-diavolo.html al diavolo il paradiso] [http://kitmun.cn/ytana.html ytana] [http://knock-knock.cn/www-f1francia/index.html www f1francia com] [http://snailtail.cn/xxx-photos/index.html xxx photos gallery] [http://bigboobs.fast-road.cn/index.html big boobs] [http://boccherinimusicanotturnamadrid.fast-road.cn/index.html boccherini musica notturna madrid] [http://bolognacinemamedusa.clung.cn/index.html bologna cinema medusa] [http://beheadingsiraq.clung.cn/index.html beheadings iraq] [http://wonted.cn/www-seyx/index.html www seyx net] [http://snailtail.cn/xxz/index.html xxz] [http://ballerinapuntocroce.kittiss.cn/index.html ballerina punto croce] [http://quoits.cn/animali-che.html animali che attraversano la strada] [http://barbiegirlaqua.kittiss.cn/index.html barbie girl aqua] [http://quoits.cn/zeno.html zeno] [http://quoits.cn/ammazzali-tutti.html ammazzali tutti e torna solo] [http://quoits.cn/zingari.html zingari] [http://bluelettrico.midways.cn/index.html blu elettrico] [http://kitmun.cn/you-could-make.html you could make a killing] [http://bonometticamper.midways.cn/index.html bonometti camper] [http://blackholesun.clung.cn/index.html black hole sun] [http://kitmun.cn/zie-porche.html zie porche] [http://knock-knock.cn/www-bancomer/index.html www bancomer com mx] [http://blacksabath.midways.cn/index.html black sabath] [http://bigliettizeligcircus.clung.cn/index.html biglietti zelig circus] [http://bellissima.fast-road.cn/index.html bellissima] [http://wonted.cn/www-econ-unito/index.html www econ unito it] [http://snailtail.cn/www-googlpe/index.html www googlpe it] [http://bode.fast-road.cn/index.html bode] [http://knock-knock.cn/www-joob-it/index.html www joob it] [http://bennibenassicalifornia.clung.cn/index.html benni benassi california] [http://bringiton.fast-road.cn/index.html bring it on] [http://wonted.cn/www-servicesport/index.html www servicesport it] [http://bristolpalace.romanikki.cn/index.html bristol palace] [http://braianadamsheaven.kittiss.cn/index.html braian adams heaven] [http://snailtail.cn/www-tope-pelose/index.html www tope pelose] [http://brunisergio.fast-road.cn/index.html bruni sergio] [http://wonted.cn/www-peugeut/index.html www peugeut] [http://bigleykenneth.midways.cn/index.html bigley kenneth] [http://bicycletires.kittiss.cn/index.html bicycle tires] [http://wonted.cn/www-utusan-com/index.html www utusan com] [http://bicyclettebleue.fast-road.cn/index.html bicyclette bleue] [http://kitmun.cn/zebra.html zebra] [http://wonted.cn/www-snavu-it/index.html www snavu it] [http://bonjovilive.midways.cn/index.html bon jovi live] [http://knock-knock.cn/www-homeinteriors/index.html www homeinteriors com mx] [http://kitmun.cn/you-promised.html you promised me] [http://bruceleewebsite.midways.cn/index.html bruce lee website] [http://snailtail.cn/www-franceculture/index.html www franceculture com] [http://bluecd.romanikki.cn/index.html blue cd] [http://snailtail.cn/yannis-plutarchos/index.html yannis plutarchos video] [http://quoits.cn/zob.html zob] [http://berlusconieaudeparfum.midways.cn/index.html berlusconi eau de parfum] {{Voice of Freedom|108083|Property, the anarchist perspective}}
+
{{Voice of Freedom|108083|Property, the anarchist perspective}}
 
{{Voice of Freedom|107341|Gift economy, as a path to anarchic society}}
 
{{Voice of Freedom|107341|Gift economy, as a path to anarchic society}}
 
{{Voice of Freedom|94350|Organised Crime vs CrimethInc}}
 
{{Voice of Freedom|94350|Organised Crime vs CrimethInc}}
Line 5: Line 5:
 
A '''gift economy''' is an [[economic system]] in which goods and services are given, rather than traded. This should in theory be beneficial because needs can be satisfied immediately, as opposed to economic stagnation caused by adverse or inappropriate trade conditions, as such in a poverty-stricken area. This is thus often the proposed solution to the [[poverty cycle]], such as in Anarcho-Communism.
 
A '''gift economy''' is an [[economic system]] in which goods and services are given, rather than traded. This should in theory be beneficial because needs can be satisfied immediately, as opposed to economic stagnation caused by adverse or inappropriate trade conditions, as such in a poverty-stricken area. This is thus often the proposed solution to the [[poverty cycle]], such as in Anarcho-Communism.
  
−
In [[Anarcho-Communism]], there is no money or market
+
In [[Anarcho-Communism]], there is no money or market—only a gift economy. Products are given away and freely distributed. However, gift economies can co-exist with [[planned economy|planned economies]], [[market economy|market economies]], and [[barter|barter economies]].
 +
 
 +
Gift economies of communal [[food]] sharing is a universal practice among ancient and modern [[hunter-gatherer]] societies, where sharing is an [[egalitarian]] safeguard against failure of any individual's daily foraging. A more elaborate version is the [[Pacific Northwest]] [[Native American]] [[potlatch]] ritual, where leaders give away large amounts of goods to their followers, strengthening group relations.
 +
 
 +
The ''sharing economy'' is an effort to describe sharing in economic terms. Yochai Benkler in his paper ''Coase's Penguin, or Linux and the Nature of the Firm'' writes that [[Ronald Coase]] described the firm as a more efficient form of production than the market. Benkler suggests a third mode of production called ''commons-based peer-production''. Charles Leadbeater writes about the ''Pro Am revolution'' and the ''Pro Am economy'' where amateurs motivated by non-economic reasons are growing in power and supporting the sharing economy. Efforts such as [[Creative Commons]] led by [[Lawrence Lessig]] encourage sharing and argue that society and corporations will benefit from sharing.
 +
 
 +
Note that there are societies where gift recipients are expected to give something in return, typically political support, military services and general loyalty, or even return gifts and favors. This was common in warrior societies where [[monarch|kings]] and [[chieftain]]s gave freely to their followers and could expect their loyal service in return. Such systems have social sanctions built in to punish freeloaders or miserly chiefs. A default punishment would be to halt gifts or services from one party to the alleged party in wrong. Typical sanctions might also include a bad reputation, formal eviction from the lord's hall, a challenge to a duel, or public ridicule. A stingy lord would find it difficult to attract followers.
 +
 
 +
== Examples ==
 +
 
 +
Gift economies can exist outside of hunter-gatherer societies or small, ungoverned groups; in certain forms, they thrive today even in huge subpopulations of first-world countries.
 +
 
 +
Traditional '''[[scientific research]]''' is an information gift economy. Scientists produce research papers and give them away through journals and conferences. Other scientists freely refer to such papers. The more citations a scientist has, the more [[prestige (sociology)|prestige]] and respect he has, which can attract funding and positions. All scientists therefore benefit from the increased pool of knowledge.
 +
 
 +
=== The free software community ===
 +
 
 +
The [[free software]] community is an information gift economy. Programmers make their [[source code]] available, allowing anyone to copy and modify/improve the code. Individual programmers gain prestige and respect, and the community as a whole benefits from better software.
 +
 
 +
In both these examples, we see that information is particularly suited to gift economics, as information can be copied and transmitted at practically no cost.
 +
 
 +
Jordan Hubbard, writing in ''Queue'' magazine ("Open Source to the Core", p.24--31, May 2004) although referring to [[open source]] as a [[barter]] economy, describes it as a gift economy: "The volunteer software engineers in the open source software community are far more likely to help those who have demonstrated their commitment to the success of the overall open source software development process." [''op. cit.'', p. 29] In other words, reciprocity is a broad community matter rather than explicit ''quid pro quo''.
 +
 
 +
===Wikipedia and other [[wiki]]s===
 +
 
 +
[[Image: doesnotcite.jpg]]
 +
 
 +
The [[Wikipedia]] web-based collaborative encyclopedia is, in most of its operations, a thriving gift economy. Hundreds of thousands of articles are available on Wikipedia, and none of their innumerable authors and editors received any material reward. Wikipedia has been constructed entirely out of gifts, and gives information freely. From time to time Wikipedia has engaged in fundraising activities, asking people to contribute funds toward operating expenses; these donated funds are gifts, albeit explicitly solicited ones. A tiny portion of Wikipedia's income comes from product sales, mostly T-shirts, mugs, and the like, with Wikipedia logos.
 +
 
 +
Because Wikipedia exists within a money economy, some expenses must be met with money, such as paying for servers, domain registration, and for certain IT work involved in server maintenance. Therefore, the information in Wikipedia is a gift economy, but some operational aspects of its website and related entities are not. [[Yahoo!|Yahoo]]'s provision of servers in Asia[http://wikimediafoundation.org/wiki/Press_releases/Wikimedia_announces_Yahoo_support] for Wikipedia is on a gift basis; there is no explicit ''[[quid pro quo]]''. However, several people raised concerns that future reciprocation may be expected, beyond the prestige. (Mook, 2005) [http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Talk:Yahoo%21_hosting]
 +
 
 +
===Other significant examples===
 +
 
 +
A gift economy is also an important cornerstone of the annual [[Burning Man]] festival, and of '''[[regiving]]''' networks, like the [[Freecycle]] network.
 +
 
 +
'''[[Hitchhiking]]''' is a gift based form of transport.
 +
 
 +
==External links==
 +
* [http://futurepositive.synearth.net/stories/storyReader%24223  Links to numerous gift economy related articles]
 +
* [http://www.benkler.org/CoasesPenguin.html Coase's Penguin, or Linux and the Nature of the Firm by Yochai Benkler]
 +
* [http://www.gift-economy.com/ A website strongly expounding the gift economy from a feminist perspective]
 +
* [http://www.gifteconomy.org/ A wiki devoted to the gift economy]
 +
 
 +
==References==
 +
*Nate Mook, [http://www.betanews.com/article/Google_Offers_to_Host_Wikipedia/1108144572 Google Offers to Host Wikipedia], Beta News, February 11, 2005. Retrieved March 2, 2005.
 +
* [[Marcel Mauss]]: ''The Gift: The Form and Reason for Exchange in Archaic Societies''. Originally published as ''Essai sur le don. Forme et raison de l'échange dans les sociétés archaïques'' in 1925, modern English edition: ISBN 039332043X.
 +
* [[Lewis Hyde]]: ''The Gift: Imagination and the Erotic Life of Property'', 1983 (ISBN 0394715195), especially part I, "A Theory of Gifts", part of which was originally published as "The Gift Must Always Move" in ''Co-Evolution Quarterly'' No. 35, Fall 1982.
 +
 
 +
[[Category:Economics]]
 +
[[Category:Alternative economy]]
 +
[[de:Geschenkökonomie]] [[fr:Économie du don]]

Revision as of 16:21, 10 September 2007

Voice of Freedom Radical Podcast logo only.png Echo of Freedom, Radical Podcast has a podcast related to this aticle
Property, the anarchist perspective 		EoF
Voice of Freedom Radical Podcast logo only.png Echo of Freedom, Radical Podcast has a podcast related to this aticle
Gift economy, as a path to anarchic society 		EoF
Voice of Freedom Radical Podcast logo only.png Echo of Freedom, Radical Podcast has a podcast related to this aticle
Organised Crime vs CrimethInc 		EoF

A gift economy is an economic system in which goods and services are given, rather than traded. This should in theory be beneficial because needs can be satisfied immediately, as opposed to economic stagnation caused by adverse or inappropriate trade conditions, as such in a poverty-stricken area. This is thus often the proposed solution to the poverty cycle, such as in Anarcho-Communism.

In Anarcho-Communism, there is no money or market—only a gift economy. Products are given away and freely distributed. However, gift economies can co-exist with planned economies, market economies, and barter economies.

Gift economies of communal food sharing is a universal practice among ancient and modern hunter-gatherer societies, where sharing is an egalitarian safeguard against failure of any individual's daily foraging. A more elaborate version is the Pacific Northwest Native American potlatch ritual, where leaders give away large amounts of goods to their followers, strengthening group relations.

The sharing economy is an effort to describe sharing in economic terms. Yochai Benkler in his paper Coase's Penguin, or Linux and the Nature of the Firm writes that Ronald Coase described the firm as a more efficient form of production than the market. Benkler suggests a third mode of production called commons-based peer-production. Charles Leadbeater writes about the Pro Am revolution and the Pro Am economy where amateurs motivated by non-economic reasons are growing in power and supporting the sharing economy. Efforts such as Creative Commons led by Lawrence Lessig encourage sharing and argue that society and corporations will benefit from sharing.

Note that there are societies where gift recipients are expected to give something in return, typically political support, military services and general loyalty, or even return gifts and favors. This was common in warrior societies where kings and chieftains gave freely to their followers and could expect their loyal service in return. Such systems have social sanctions built in to punish freeloaders or miserly chiefs. A default punishment would be to halt gifts or services from one party to the alleged party in wrong. Typical sanctions might also include a bad reputation, formal eviction from the lord's hall, a challenge to a duel, or public ridicule. A stingy lord would find it difficult to attract followers.

Examples

Gift economies can exist outside of hunter-gatherer societies or small, ungoverned groups; in certain forms, they thrive today even in huge subpopulations of first-world countries.

Traditional scientific research is an information gift economy. Scientists produce research papers and give them away through journals and conferences. Other scientists freely refer to such papers. The more citations a scientist has, the more prestige and respect he has, which can attract funding and positions. All scientists therefore benefit from the increased pool of knowledge.

The free software community

The free software community is an information gift economy. Programmers make their source code available, allowing anyone to copy and modify/improve the code. Individual programmers gain prestige and respect, and the community as a whole benefits from better software.

In both these examples, we see that information is particularly suited to gift economics, as information can be copied and transmitted at practically no cost.

Jordan Hubbard, writing in Queue magazine ("Open Source to the Core", p.24--31, May 2004) although referring to open source as a barter economy, describes it as a gift economy: "The volunteer software engineers in the open source software community are far more likely to help those who have demonstrated their commitment to the success of the overall open source software development process." [op. cit., p. 29] In other words, reciprocity is a broad community matter rather than explicit quid pro quo.

Wikipedia and other wikis

File:doesnotcite.jpg

The Wikipedia web-based collaborative encyclopedia is, in most of its operations, a thriving gift economy. Hundreds of thousands of articles are available on Wikipedia, and none of their innumerable authors and editors received any material reward. Wikipedia has been constructed entirely out of gifts, and gives information freely. From time to time Wikipedia has engaged in fundraising activities, asking people to contribute funds toward operating expenses; these donated funds are gifts, albeit explicitly solicited ones. A tiny portion of Wikipedia's income comes from product sales, mostly T-shirts, mugs, and the like, with Wikipedia logos.

Because Wikipedia exists within a money economy, some expenses must be met with money, such as paying for servers, domain registration, and for certain IT work involved in server maintenance. Therefore, the information in Wikipedia is a gift economy, but some operational aspects of its website and related entities are not. Yahoo's provision of servers in Asia[1] for Wikipedia is on a gift basis; there is no explicit quid pro quo. However, several people raised concerns that future reciprocation may be expected, beyond the prestige. (Mook, 2005) [2]

Other significant examples

A gift economy is also an important cornerstone of the annual Burning Man festival, and of regiving networks, like the Freecycle network.

Hitchhiking is a gift based form of transport.

External links

References

  • Nate Mook, Google Offers to Host Wikipedia, Beta News, February 11, 2005. Retrieved March 2, 2005.
  • Marcel Mauss: The Gift: The Form and Reason for Exchange in Archaic Societies. Originally published as Essai sur le don. Forme et raison de l'échange dans les sociétés archaïques in 1925, modern English edition: ISBN 039332043X.
  • Lewis Hyde: The Gift: Imagination and the Erotic Life of Property, 1983 (ISBN 0394715195), especially part I, "A Theory of Gifts", part of which was originally published as "The Gift Must Always Move" in Co-Evolution Quarterly No. 35, Fall 1982.
Retrieved from "http://eng.anarchopedia.org/index.php?title=gift_economy&oldid=25666"