Still working to recover. Please don't edit quite yet.

Difference between revisions of "Anarchopedia:Utility"

From Anarchopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
(Start)
 
(Note)
 
(4 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 4: Line 4:
  
 
= Balance =
 
= Balance =
−
{{main|Anarchopedia:Truth#Balance}} (shortcut A:T#B)
+
{{main|Anarchopedia:Truth#Balance}}
 +
shortcut A:T#B
  
 
Balance with reference to Utility; while Truth is of uppermost importance, Balance is preferred; mostly because of Justice but Completeness is almost as important a rationale in this case
 
Balance with reference to Utility; while Truth is of uppermost importance, Balance is preferred; mostly because of Justice but Completeness is almost as important a rationale in this case
  
 
== Point of View ==
 
== Point of View ==
−
{{main|Anarchopedia:POV}} (shortcut A:POV)
+
{{main|Anarchopedia:POV}}
−
Most of the thinking of the world's ruling class is skewed toward support of a murderous, damaging, unfair, inefficient and in many other ways erroneous system.
+
shortcut A:POV
  
−
One of the ways this is achieved is to propose Point of View as a relative thing, and both sides of the political spectrum find this convenient; the Right obviously because it can never be challenged on moral grounds as long as morality is mere opinion, and the Left in fear of seeming unreasonable. However, this is an unnecessary compromise, and erroneous itself.
+
* Most thinking is skewed; one of the ways this is achieved is to propose Point of View as a relative thing.
 +
* The best ideas have less probability of being shared by the majority.
 +
* One of the supports for the idea of PoV is the assumption of bias; this amounts to nothing more than [[Wikipedia:Tu Quoque|"You would say that" (Tu Quoque)]]. Obviously we want more people to learn more faster, but we should not be surprised if the people who most want to learn are those with the most vested interest.
  
−
Wikipedia treats PoV, through Notability, as non-mainstream, which is patently absurd. There is no more statistical probability of the majority being right than there is that the majority will get A's in school. As this example shows, it is in fact the opposite; although views are not necessarily right because they are non-mainstream, either :) , the chances are that the best ideas will probably not be shared by the majority.
+
== Notability ==
 +
Utility also replaces, to a large extent, Notability. Notability has numerous problems, among them the laughable mashup of the rules: Notability vs "Notability is not inherited". Really? But that is all that notability IS... value inherited from the supposed merit of the sources it uses, reflected glory.
  
−
One of the supports for the idea of PoV is the assumption of bias; this amounts to nothing more than [[Wikipedia:Tu Quoque|"You would say that" (Tu Quoque)]]. It takes a great deal more work than is normally credited, to fill a mind, and impossible to fill it from things utterly outside one's personal experience. Personal experience makes firmer and more far-reaching neural pathways; if experience -living through certain events- or intentionally living -a certain way- is required to overcome the conditioning of mainstream society, then it is for the best, and there is no more benefit from criticizing this relationship between perception and truth than there is in criticizing any other useful process. Obviously we want more people to learn more faster, but we should not be surprised if the people who most want to learn are those with the most vested interest.
+
== See also ==
 +
* [[Anarchopedia:Consensus building]]
 +
* [[Anarchopedia:Point of View]] shortcut A:POV
 +
* [[Anarchopedia:Subjective]]
 +
* [[Anarchopedia:Truth]] (shortcut A:T)
 +
** Balance [[A:T#B]]
 +
* Anarchopedia:Utility (shortcut [[A:U]])
 +
[[Category:Anarchopedia]][[Category:Anarchopedia guidelines]]

Latest revision as of 13:54, 8 August 2012

Anarchopedia is useful. The use that people gain from it may only be an aesthetic one, but it is as useful as possible, and always more useful than not.

This is not merely an answer to Wikipedia's USEFUL rule, which is more erroneous than the average WP rule. Utility answers a great deal of problems that confront a compendium of subjective information (which every wiki including WP will always contain, despite its obfuscation of the issue): balance, PoV, whether it is OK to use biased sources to extract useful information (and it is not always OK)

Balance[edit]

shortcut A:T#B

Balance with reference to Utility; while Truth is of uppermost importance, Balance is preferred; mostly because of Justice but Completeness is almost as important a rationale in this case

Point of View[edit]

Main article: Anarchopedia:POV

shortcut A:POV

  • Most thinking is skewed; one of the ways this is achieved is to propose Point of View as a relative thing.
  • The best ideas have less probability of being shared by the majority.
  • One of the supports for the idea of PoV is the assumption of bias; this amounts to nothing more than "You would say that" (Tu Quoque). Obviously we want more people to learn more faster, but we should not be surprised if the people who most want to learn are those with the most vested interest.

Notability[edit]

Utility also replaces, to a large extent, Notability. Notability has numerous problems, among them the laughable mashup of the rules: Notability vs "Notability is not inherited". Really? But that is all that notability IS... value inherited from the supposed merit of the sources it uses, reflected glory.

See also[edit]