Still working to recover. Please don't edit quite yet.

Torture by nations participating in extraordinary rendition

From Anarchopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

This subject has been split into multiple articles due to the large amount of material


Extraordinary rendition and irregular rendition describe the abduction and extrajudicial transfer of a person from one nation to another.[1] "Torture by proxy" is such a transfer to countries known to practice torture, with the intention of torturing the person by proxy at the destination location.[2][3][4] Torture by proxy is denied by the US, but documented evidence of it exists,[5] and a Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe report concluded that it was "credible": "The elements we have gathered so far tend to reinforce the credibility of the allegations concerning the transport and temporary detention of detainees — outside all judicial procedure - in European countries."[6] The chairman of the PACE stated "he was personally convinced the US had undertaken illegal activities in Europe in transporting and detaining prisoners."[7]


Khaled Masri case[edit]

See Wikipedia:Khaled El-Masri

Abu Omar case[edit]

See Wikipedia:Imam Rapito affair

On February 17, 2003, Hassan Mustafa Osama Nasr (aka "Abu Omar") was kidnapped by the CIA in Milan (Italy),[8] and deported to Egypt. His case has been qualified by Swiss senator Dick Marty to be a "perfect example of extraordinary rendition".[9] Abu Omar was kidnapped as he walked to his mosque in Milan for noon prayers.[10] From there, he was flown by a Lear jet (using the call sign SPAR 92) to Ramstein, Germany. SPAR (Special Air Resources) is the call sign used by US senior military officers and civilian VIPs for airlift transport[11][12] A second plane then took him to Cairo, where he was imprisoned and, he claims, tortured.[13] At the time of his disappearance, Italian police were investigating allegations that Nasr had tried to recruit jihadists.Template:Citation needed Prosecutor Amarando Spataro, known for his aggressive investigations of leading Mafia figures, said the abduction was illegal because it violated Italian sovereignty, while also disrupting an ongoing police investigation.verify please

On December 6, 2005, the Washington Post reported Italian court documents which showed that the CIA tried to mislead Italian anti-terrorism police who were looking for the cleric at the time. Robert Seldon Lady, the CIA's substation chief in Milan, has been implicated in the abduction. In a written opinion upholding the arrest warrant, judge Enrico Manzi wrote that the evidence taken from Lady's home "removes any doubt about his participation in the preparatory phase of the abduction."[14] Robert S. Lady however, alleged that the evidence has been gathered illegally, and has denied involvement in the abduction.[15] Photos of Robert (Bob) Lady and other defendants recently have surfaced on the Web.[16]

In June 2005, Italian judge Guido Salvini issued a warrant for the arrest of 13 persons said to be agents or operatives of the CIA. In December 2005, an Italian court issued a European arrest warrant against 22 CIA agents suspected of this kidnapping (including Robert Seldon Lady, Eliana Castaldo, Lt. Col. Joseph L. Romano, III, etc.[17]). Just after the 2006 Italian general elections, Roberto Castelli (Lega Nord), outgoing Justice Minister, declared to Italian prosecutors that he had not passed the extradition request to the US.Template:Citation needed

Furthermore, Marco Mancini, the SISMI director of anti-terrorism and counterespionage, and Gustavo Pignero, the department's director in 2003, have been arrested, on charges of complicity in a kidnapping with the aggravating circumstances of abuse of power. There are now 26 EU arrest warrants for U.S. citizens in connection to this event.[18] A judge also issued arrest warrants for four Americans, three CIA agents and an Air Force officer who commanded the security forces at Aviano Air Base at the time of the abduction.[19]

On February 12, 2007, Mr Nasr's lawyer said he had been released and was back with his family.[20]

On November 4, 2009, an Italian judge convicted 22 suspected or known CIA agents, a U.S. Air Force (USAF) colonel and two Italian secret agents of the kidnap, delivering the first legal convictions in the world against people involved in the CIA's extraordinary renditions program. The CIA has not commented on the case, while Berlusconi's government has denied any knowledge of a kidnapping plot.[21]

Majid Mahmud Abdu Ahmad case[edit]

See #Torture by proxy

A story in the Los Angeles Times on December 8, 2005 seems to corroborate the claims of "torture by proxy." It mentions the attorneys for Majid Mahmud Abdu Ahmad, a detainee held by the Pentagon at Guantanamo Bay, filed a petition to prevent his being transferred to foreign countries. According to the petition's description of a redacted classified Defense Department memo from March 17, 2004, its contents say "officials suggested sending Ahmad to an unspecified foreign country that employed torture in order to increase chances of extracting information from him."[5]

Mr Falkoff, representing Ahmad, continued: "There is only one meaning that can be gleaned from this short passage," the petition says. "The government believes that Mr. Ahmad has information that it wants but that it cannot extract without torturing him." The petition goes on to say that because torture is not allowed at Guantanamo, "the recommendation is that Mr. Ahmad should be sent to another country where he can be interrogated under torture."[5]

In a report, regarding the allegations of CIA flights, on December 13, 2005, by the rapporteur and Chair of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe's Committee on Legal Affairs and Human Rights, Swiss councillor Dick Marty, it was concluded: "The elements we have gathered so far tend to reinforce the credibility of the allegations concerning the transport and temporary detention of detainees — outside all judicial procedure - in European countries."[6] In a press conference in January 2006, he stated "he was personally convinced the US had undertaken illegal activities in Europe in transporting and detaining prisoners."[7]

Muhammad Bashmila case[edit]

Muhammad Bashmila, a former secret prisoner, now free in Yemen, gave an interview to the BBC Newsnight programme, where he spoke of being transferred from Afghanistan to a detention center where it was cold, where the food appeared European and where evening prayers were held. Somewhere in Eastern Europe is suspected.[22]

Maher Arar case[edit]

Maher Arar, a Syrian-born dual Syrian and Canadian citizen, was detained at Kennedy International Airport on 26 September 2002, by US Immigration and Naturalization Service officials. He was heading home to Canada after a family holiday in Tunisia. After almost two weeks, enduring hours of interrogation chained, he was sent, shackled and bound, in a private jet to Jordan and then Syria, instead of being extradited to Canada. There, he was interrogated and tortured by Syrian intelligence. Maher Arar was eventually released a year later. He told the BBC that he was repeatedly tortured during 10 months' detention in Syria — often whipped on the palms of his hands with metal cables. Syrian intelligence officers forced him to sign a confession linking him to Al Qaeda. He was finally released following intervention by the Canadian government. The Canadian government lodged an official complaint with the US government protesting Arar's deportation. On September 18, 2006, a Canadian public enquiry presented its findings entirely clearing Arar of any terrorist activities.[23] In 2004 Arar filed a lawsuit in a federal court in New York against senior U.S. officials, on charges that whoever sent him to Syria knew he would be tortured by intelligence agents.[24] US Attorney General John Ashcroft, Homeland Security Secretary Tom Ridge and FBI Director Robert Mueller are all named in the lawsuit.[25] On October 18, 2006, Arar received the Letelier-Moffitt Human Rights Award from the Institute for Policy Studies for his ordeal. On October 18, 2007, Maher Arar received apologies from the U.S. House of Representatives. Nevertheless, U.S. Representative Dana Rohrabacher, who also apologized, stated that he would fight any efforts to end the practice.[26]

Mohamed et al. v. Jeppesen Dataplan, Inc.[edit]


Other cases[edit]

This is a non-exhaustive list of some known examples of extraordinary rendition.

  • A Pakistani newspaper reported that in the early hours of October 23, 2001 a Yemeni citizen, Jamil Qasim Saeed Mohammed, a 27-year-old microbiology student at Karachi University, was spirited aboard a private plane at Karachi's airport by Pakistani security officers.[27]
  • In October 2001, Mamdouh Habib, who lives in Australia and has both Australian and Egyptian nationality (having been born in Egypt), was detained in Pakistan, where he was interrogated for three weeks, and then flown to Egypt in a private plane. From Egypt, he was later flown to a US airbase in Afghanistan. He told the BBC that he did not know who had held him, but had seen Americans, Australians, Pakistanis, and Egyptians among his captors. He also said that he had been beaten, given electric shocks, deprived of sleep, blindfolded for eight months and brainwashed.[24] After signing confessions of involvement with al-Qaeda, which he has now retracted, Mr Habib was transferred to Guantanamo Bay. He was released without charge in January 2005.[28] Former Pakistani Interior Minister Makhdoom Syed Faisal Sawleh Hayat told in an interview by the Australian current affairs programme Dateline that Mr Habib was linked with the "terrorist element" operating at that time. However, he contradicted himself a few minutes later, in the same interview, saying that Habib had been assumed guilty because he was in the restricted province of Baluchistan without proper visa documents.[29]
  • In 2002, captured Al Qaeda leader Ibn al-Shaykh al-Libi was rendered to Egypt where he was allegedly tortured. The information he provided to his interrogators formed a fundamental part of the Bush administration case for attacking Iraq, alleging links between Al Qaeda and Iraq. Al-Libi later recanted his story and it is generally believed that his stories of contact between the Saddam Hussein regime and Al-Qaeda were fabricated to please his interrogators.[30]
  • Ahmed Agiza and Muhammad al-Zery, two Egyptians who had been seeking asylum in Sweden, were arrested by Swedish police in December 2001. They were taken to Bromma airport in Stockholm, had their clothes cut from their bodies, suppositories inserted in their anuses and in diapers, overall, handcuffs and chains put on an executive jet with American registration N379P with a crew of masked men. They were flown to Egypt, where they were imprisoned, beaten, and tortured according to reports by Swedish investigative pogramme "Kalla fakta"[31] The Swedish ambassador visited them only six weeks later. Agiza was previously charged and sentenced in absentia with being an Islamic militant and was sentenced to 25 years, a sentence that was reduced to 15 years due to the political pressure after the Rendition became known. Al-Zery wasn't charged, and after two years in jail withouth ever seeing a judge or prosecutor he was sent to his village in Egypt. In 2008 AL Zery was awarded 500 000 dollars in damages by the Swedish government for the wrongful treatment he received in Sweden and the subsequent torture in Egypt.
  • In March 2002, Abou Elkassim Britel, an Italian citizen with Moroccan origins, was arrested in Pakistan and subsequently interrogated by Pakistani and US officials. He was then rendered to Moroccan authorities, detained and torture in a secret detention center in Temara. He was finally released without any charges brought against him, before being rearrested in May 2003 at the border crossing of the Spanish enclave of Melilla in North Africa. He is currently imprisoned in Äin Bourja prison in Casablanca after having been sentenced to nine years in January 2004 for membership of a subversive organisation and for activities including the holding unauthorised meetings. This in spite of conclusions in September 2006 by Italian Justice, after a five years investigation, that there was "an absolute lack of grounds of evidence of charge which may be used in trial" and that the suspicion motivating the inquiries had proved unfounded. Nonetheless, allegations in the Italian press and the judicial proceedings that were underway in Italy influenced court proceedings against Britel in Morocco that led to him being sentenced. MPs from Italy and from the European Parliament are set to ask the Moroccan Royal Cabinet to grant a pardon to the Italian citizen[32] According to the European Parliament Temporary Committee on the Alleged Use of European Countries by the CIA for the Transport and the Illegal Detention of Prisoners headed by rapporteur Giovanni Claudio Fava, documents demonstrated that "the Italian judicial authorities and the Italian Ministry for Home Affairs (the latter, acting on behalf of the Direzione Centrale della Polizia di Prevenzione cited in connection with the investigation by the Divisione Investigazioni Generali ed Operazioni Speciali) cooperated constantly with foreign secret services and were well aware of all Britel's movements and whatever unlawful treatments he received, from the time of his initial arrest in Pakistan."[33]
  • In 2003, an Algerian named Laid Saidi was abducted in Tanzania and taken to Afghanistan, where he was imprisoned and tortured along with Khalid El-Masri.[34] His detention appears to have arisen through a mistranslation of a telephone conversation, in which U.S. officials believed he was speaking about airplanes (tairat in Arabic) when he had in fact been speaking about tires (tirat in Arabic).
  • Binyam Mohammed, an Ethiopian student who lived in London, was apprehended in Pakistan in April 2002. He allegedly spent three years in "black sites," including in Morocco and Afghanistan. He was supposed to be part of a plot involving José Padilla. The Observer reported: "He went to Pakistan in June 2001 because, he says, he had a drug problem and wanted to kick the habit. He was arrested on 10 April at the airport on his way back to England because of an alleged passport irregularity. Initially interrogated by Pakistani and British officials, he told Stafford Smith: 'The British checked out my story and said they knew I was a nobody. They said they would tell the Americans." He was deprived of sleep by having heavy rock music played loudly throughout the day and night.[24][35]
  • In late 2001 Saddiq Ahmad Turkistani was freed by US forces from a Taliban prison in Kandahar, Afghanistan. At a news conference he told reporters and U.S. officials he had been wrongly imprisoned for allegedly plotting to kill Osama bin Laden. He was then taken to a U.S. military base in Afghanistan, where he was stripped, bound and thrown behind bars. According to U.S. lawyers who represent him, in January 2002 he was sent to the U.S. detention facility at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. Nearly four years later, Turkistani remains there, despite being cleared for release early 2005 after a government review concluded he is "no longer an enemy combatant." It is unclear exactly when that determination was made, but Justice Department lawyers gave notice of it in an October 11 court filing.[36] According to a June 26, 2006 press release from the Saudi Arabian embassy,[37] Turkistani was released from Guantanamo to Saudi custody
  • On 5 April 2006, Amnesty International released details of the United States' system of extraordinary rendition, stating that three Yemeni citizens were held somewhere in Eastern Europe.[38]
  • On February 22, 2008 a report from Amnesty International stated that there was an "admission by the US and UK governments that two rendition flights had landed in Diego Garcia in 2002."[39]
  • The case of Mohammed Haydar Zammar


See Also and References[edit]

See Extraordinary Rendition

  1. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named MJC-2006-04-05
  2. Daphen Eviatar (2009-01-26). "Torture Case Tests Obama Secrecy Policy: Will Obama Administration Break From Bush on Extraordinary Rendition?". Washington Independent. Archived from the original on 2009-11-05. http://www.webcitation.org/query?url=http%3A%2F%2Fwashingtonindependent.com%2F27199%2Ftorture-case-poses-early-state-secret-test&date=2009-11-05. "Mohamed v. Jeppesen Dataplan, Inc. involves five victims of CIA rendition, or “torture by proxy,” as it’s also known." </li>
  3. Daphen Eviatar (2009-06-12). "Obama Administration Seeks Re-Hearing in Extraordinary Rendition Case". Washington Independent. Archived from the original on 2009-11-05. http://www.webcitation.org/query?url=http%3A%2F%2Fwashingtonindependent.com%2F46882%2Fobama-administration-seeks-re-hearing-in-extraordinary-rendition-case&date=2009-11-05. "As I’ve written before, Mohamed v. Jeppesen Dataplan involves five victims of CIA rendition, or “torture by proxy” who sued the subsidiary of Boeing that allegedly helped the CIA fly the men, captured abroad, to secret CIA prisons in cooperating countries." </li>
  4. "Torture by proxy: International law applicable to ‘Extraordinary Renditions’". All Party Parliamentary Group on Extraordinary Rendition. 2005-12. Archived from the original on 2009-11-05. http://www.webcitation.org/query?url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.chrgj.org%2Fdocs%2FAPPG-NYU%2520Briefing%2520Paper.pdf&date=2009-11-05. </li>
  5. 5.0 5.1 5.2 Ken, Silverstein (December 8, 2005). "Pentagon Memo on Torture-Motivated Transfer cited.". Los Angeles Times. http://articles.latimes.com/2005/dec/08/nation/na-torture8. </li>
  6. 6.0 6.1 "CIA abduction claims 'credible'". BBC News Online. December 13, 2005. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/4524864.stm. Retrieved 2005-12-18. </li>
  7. 7.0 7.1 "Europe 'complicit over CIA jails'". BBC News Online. January 14, 2006. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/4611518.stm. Retrieved 2006-09-07. </li>
  8. Piano/Esteri/2005/11 Novembre/11/imam.shtml "Foto della Cia svela il sequestro dell'imam", Corriere della Sera, 12 novembre 2005.
  9. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named Bbc060124
  10. Auditions sur le rapt d'un imam par la CIA, Le Figaro, February 24, 2006 (French)
  11. Hooper, J. (2005). "CIA methods exposed by kidnap inquiry". The Guardian UK, July 2, 2005.
  12. US military planes criss-cross Europe using bogus call sign, The Sunday Times, February 19, 2006 Template:en icon
  13. Wilkinson, T. and G. Miller. (2005). "Italy Says It Didn't Know of CIA Plan". The Los Angeles Times, July 1, 2005.
  14. Whitlock, Craig (December 6, 2005). "CIA Ruse is Said to Have Damaged Probe in Milan: Italy Allegedly Misled on Cleric's Abduction". Washington Post. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/12/04/AR2005120400885.html. Retrieved 2005-12-18. </li>
  15. "Former CIA Agent to Fight Italian Warrant". Associated Press. December 9, 2005. http://www.blythe-systems.com/pipermail/nytr/Week-of-Mon-20051205/028234.html. Retrieved 2009-06-23. </li>
  16. Renditioner photos: Wanted Poster for CIA's Robert Lady in Imam Rapito, Indymedia San Francisco, March 30, 2007.
  17. Template:PDFlink, published by Statewatch, June 22, 2005
  18. Italians held over 'CIA kidnap', BBC News Online, 5 July 2006; retrieved on 2007-01-27
  19. Italian Spies Arrested, Americans Sought for Kidnap, Reuters cable, July 5, 2006, mirrored by Commondreams
  20. Egypt releases 'rendition' cleric, BBC News Online, 12 February 2007
  21. "EU-wide warrant over 'CIA kidnap'". BBC News Online. December 23, 2005. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/4555660.stm. Retrieved 2006-09-07. </li>
  22. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named BBC_NOL_2006-06-07
  23. Template:PDFlink, Commission of Inquiry into the Actions of Canadian Officials in Relation to Maher Arar
  24. 24.0 24.1 24.2 Renditions: Tales of Torture, BBC News Online, December 7, 2005
  25. Canadian sues US over deportation, BBC News Online, 23 January 2004
  26. [1], CBCNews, October 18, 2007
  27. "Jet is an Open Secret in Terror War". Washington Post. December 27, 2004. http://www.washingtonpost.com/ac2/wp-dyn/A27826-2004Dec26?language=printer. Retrieved 2007-02-12. </li>
  28. "'Tortured' Australian speaks out". BBC News Online. December 7, 2005. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/asia-pacific/4505886.stm. Retrieved 2005-12-18. </li>
  29. Profile: Mamdouh Habib, BBC News Online, December 7, 2005
  30. Jeffery, Simon (December 9, 2005). "Prewar claims 'sourced from rendition detainee'". The Guardian (London). http://www.guardian.co.uk/Iraq/Story/0,2763,1663743,00.html. Retrieved 2005-12-18. </li>
  31. Kalla fakta 20040518 http://www.trojkan.se/temp/Reportage/KF%20The%20Broken%20Promise%20Extraordinary%20Rendition/
  32. Renditions: Italian and European MPs set to request pardon for Abou Elkassim Britel, Statewatch, January 2007 Template:en icon
  33. Template:PDFlink, Rapporteur Giovanni Claudio Fava, European Parliament DT/65174EN.doc 7 February 2007, made accessible by Statewatch, accessed on 18 February 2007 Template:en icon
  34. Smith, Craig S.; Mekhennet, Souad (July 7, 2006). "Algerian Tells of Dark Odyssey in U.S. Hands". New York Times. http://www.nytimes.com/2006/07/07/world/africa/07algeria.html?ei=5090&en=17b76be0aba70618&ex=1309924800&partner=rssuserland&emc=rss&pagewanted=all. Retrieved 2006-09-07. </li>
  35. "MI6 and CIA 'sent student to Morocco to be tortured'". The Guardian (London). December 11, 2005. http://observer.guardian.co.uk/international/story/0%2C6903%2C1664612%2C00.html. Retrieved 2005-12-18. </li>
  36. White, Josh; Wright, Robin (December 15, 2005). "Detainee Cleared for Release Is in Limbo at Guantanamo". The Washington Post. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/12/14/AR2005121402125.html. Retrieved 2005-12-18. </li>
  37. Fourteen Guantanamo detainees returned to the Kingdom, Royal Embassy of Saudi Arabia in Washington DC, June 25, 2006
  38. Below the radar: Secret flights to torture and ‘disappearance’. Archived from source April 12, 2006. URL accessed on 2006-04-05.
  39. UK/US: Revelations about detention flights in Diego Garcia highlight need for full inquiry | Amnesty International. Amnesty.org. URL accessed on 2010-07-17.
  40. </ol>